Cleaning your pool is essential to keep the water clear, healthy and pleasant for swimming. There are two main options available to owners: the manual or automatic pool vacuum cleaner, and the robot cleaner, which is more autonomous and often more high-tech. Should you opt for the simplicity of a vacuum cleaner like the Kokido Vektro XL or invest in a smart robot like the Beatbot AquaSense 2 Ultra? Each solution has its advantages and limitations. Here is a comprehensive comparison to help you make the right choice according to your budget, your expectations... and your level of tolerance to effort.
How manual pool cleaners work
Manual pool cleaners are portable devices, often cordless, that are plunged directly into the pool to vacuum up dirt. The
Kokido Vektro XL, for example, is a practical, lightweight, cable-free model capable of removing debris from the bottom. It is ideal for small above-ground pools and spas, or as a complement to another cleaning system. Its main advantage is its affordable price. On the other hand, it requires
manual intervention: you have to guide the device over the entire surface to be treated. For large swimming pools, this quickly becomes time-consuming and tiring. It is therefore more of an additional solution than a complete system. Electric robots, especially the latest generation such as the
Beatbot AquaSense, offer total autonomy. Equipped with their own drive motor, they brush, vacuum and filter completely independently, without needing to be connected to the pool filtration system. Some models, such as the
AquaSense 2 Pro or the
Ultra, are even equipped with AI and
HybridSense™ technology with an on-board camera to map the pool and optimise their route.
These robots cover not only the bottom, but also the walls and waterline, for
complete cleaning without effort. They represent a more substantial investment, but this is largely offset by their efficiency, time savings and ease of use.
Selection criteria: budget, pool size and maintenance frequency
To make the right choice between a vacuum cleaner and a robot, you need to consider:
- The size of the pool: a vacuum cleaner is suitable for compact pools, while a robot is essential for pools of 20-25 m² or more.
- Frequency of maintenance: for daily or weekly cleaning without hassle, a robot is the best solution.
- Budget: a vacuum cleaner like the Vektro XL costs €100 to €200, while a top-of-the-range robot ranges between €800 and €1600 depending on its features.
A surface cleaner, such as Beatbot's
iSkim Ultra, can also complement a manual vacuum cleaner by keeping the pool surface clean on a daily basis.
Maintenance and durability: different approaches
A pool vacuum cleaner requires little maintenance: rinsing it after each use is usually enough. However, its battery generally offers
less autonomy than a robot, and its lifespan may be limited under intensive use. Robots, on the other hand, require more care (cleaning the filters, checking the wheels and brushes) but are designed to last several seasons without fail. Beatbot models feature high-capacity batteries with vertical wireless charging, dual-level ClearWater™ filtration and mobile app control—a real plus for those who want to monitor the status of their device remotely.
On-board technology and ease of use
This is where robots clearly have the advantage. With
HybridSense™ AI technology, Beatbot robots adapt their cleaning to the dirtiest areas, avoid obstacles and optimise their route. Their smart functionality allows for more targeted, faster and more energy-efficient maintenance. A vacuum cleaner, even a high-performance one, remains a manual device that cannot anticipate cleaning areas or adjust its power or trajectory. It requires constant human intervention, which can be a hindrance for users seeking a truly autonomous solution.
Two solutions for two very different needs
The choice between a pool vacuum cleaner and a robot ultimately depends on your needs. For a small pool, occasional use or as a supplementary device, a model like the
Kokido Vektro XL may suffice. However, for regular, autonomous and thorough maintenance, robots such as the Beatbot AquaSense 2 Ultra are essential. Their cutting-edge technology, energy autonomy, smart control and 360° cleaning capacity (bottom, walls, waterline) make them a valuable daily ally. And if you add a surface cleaner such as the iSkim Ultra, you get a permanently clean pool... without any effort.